Favrot Lecture with Dr. Mary Blair-Loy: Misconceiving Merit in Academic STEM . . . and What To Do About It

Event Date
-
H*ert Hall, Room 201
Favrot Lecture with Dr. Mary Blair-Loy: Misconceiving Merit in Academic STEM . . . and What To Do About It illustration

In Misconceiving Merit, Mary Blair-Loy & Erin A. Cech uncover the cultural foundations of a paradox. On one hand, academic science, engineering, and math revere meritocracy, a system that recognizes and rewards those with the greatest talent and dedication. At the same time, underrepresented groups are devalued. How can academic science, which so highly values meritocracy and objectivity, produce these unequal outcomes?

Blair-Loy & Cech studied more than five hundred STEM professors at a top research university to reveal how unequal outcomes can emerge alongside sincere commitments to objectivity and excellence. The authors find that academic STEM harbors dominant cultural beliefs -- about what work devotion is and what scientific excellence should look like— that persistently shape interactions and legitimize this unfair treatment. Underrepresented groups – including women from all racial/ethnic backgrounds, Black and Latinx men, and LBGTQ-identifying faculty -- are often seen as less fully embodying merit than equally productive white and Asian heterosexual men. These negative career consequences persist regardless of professors’ actual academic productivity, and they help undermine scientific innovation.

What can we do about this? Blair-Loy will share highlights from recent research on Early Career Scientists to explore how campuses and disciplines could address these patterns.